Comments and Excerpts concerning the reoccurrence
of the Ice Age and its cause.
Sections:
1 Ice Age 2 Glacial Advances 3 Climate 4 Geology
Biblical commentary on Planetary convulsions -
Astronomical Theory Offers New Explanation For Ice Age
By Jeffery Kahn, JBKahn@LBL.gov
July 11, 1997
BERKELEY, CA -
Researchers Richard A. Muller of the Ernest Orlando Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (Berkeley Lab), and Gordon J. MacDonald of the International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis, Austria, are co-
Muller and MacDonald report that cyclical changes in the location of the Earth's orbit cause differing quantities of extraterrestrial debris to come into the Earth's atmosphere. This, in turn, results in variations of climate on the planet.
Said MacDonald, "As the Earth moves up and down in the plane of the solar system, it runs into various amounts of debris, dust and meteoroids. Our work was an outgrowth of investigations of larger impacts, such as the comet or asteroid that killed the dinosaurs. However, meteoroids and dust are much smaller and more spread-
Muller notes that this new research has important implications for the understanding of the present climate, and for predictions of future climate.
"As far as we know," he said, "none of the present climate models include the effects of dust and meteors. And yet our data suggests that such accretion played the dominant role in the climate for the last million years. If we wish to make accurate predictions, we must understand the role played by such material."
Despite the current relatively warm climate on Earth, regular recurring epochs of glaciation have dominated the planet for the past million years. Ten times, glaciers have advanced and then retreated with the duration of retreat (and corresponding warmth) frequently lasting not more than 10,000 years. The Earth has been in a warm period for about 10,000 years now.
In the paper in Science, the researchers compared the geological record to the climactic cycles that would result from their theory and to that of the competing theory, first published in 1912 by Serbian scientist Milutin Milankovitch. Using a geological fingerprinting technique, Muller and MacDonald found that the climactic changes recorded in the rocks matched their theory but not that of Milankovitch.
Milankovitch said the ice ages are caused by variations in sunlight hitting the continents. In his theory, the ice ages are linked to "eccentricity," a very gradual, cyclic change in the shape of the Earth's egg-
To visualize the different astronomical cycle that Muller and MacDonald have found to match that of the climatic record, imagine a flat plane with the sun in the center and nine planets circling close to the plane. In fact, all the planets orbit the sun close to such a fixed orbital plane. The Earth's orbit slowly tilts out of this plane and then returns. As Muller first calculated in 1993, the cycle of tilt repeats every 100,000 years.
In their Science paper, Muller and MacDonald examine the geological record of the past million years to see which of the two 100,000-
They applied a technique called spectral analysis to ocean sediments taken from eight locations around the world, examining the oxygen-
Muller and MacDonald's analysis yields "spectral fingerprints" which can be compared to the predictions of the two theories. Their analysis shows a clear pattern: The fingerprints of the ice ages show a single dominant feature, a peak with a period of 100,000 years. This precisely matches their theory. The fingerprints do not match the expected trio of peaks predicted by the Milankovitch theory.
Said Muller, "The mechanism proposed by Milankovitch could be adjusted to explain the cycles of glaciation that occurred prior to one million years ago. However, for the past million years the glacial record is an excellent match to the cycle of tilt."
Berkeley Lab conducts unclassified scientific research for the U.S. Department of Energy. It is located in Berkeley, California and is managed by the University of California.
-
-
* Pleistocene (ice age of the past 2 million years)
* Pennsylvanian/Permian (around 250 million years ago).
* Late Precambrian (around 600 million years ago)
-
-
-
-
* Identify distinct layers of till separated by paleosols (ancient soil horizons).
* Marine record (better preserved) contains evidence for more than 20 advances. Geologists look at isotopes in plankton shells, because these depend on temperature, so it's possible for them to determine when the oceans were warmer, and when they were colder.
II) Causes of Ice Ages
(1) Long-
-
-
-
* CO2 is a "greenhouse gas" (traps heat in the atmosphere)
-
-
-
(2) Short-
-
age probably are controlled by the Milankovitch cycle (a periodic change in the tilt of the Earth's axis and the ellipticity of the Earth's orbit).
-
-
-
III) Idealized Scenario of Glacial Advance and Retreat during an Ice Age:
1) Milankovitch conditions are appropriate for ice to accumulate. Glaciers advance.
2) Land becomes covered with snow and ice, so albedo (reflectivity) increases. Because sunlight is reflected by earth's surface, rather than absorbed, the earth gets even cooler. So glaciers continue to grow.
3) Water gets stored in the ice sheet, so sea level drops (continental shelf becomes dry land). Also, ocean freezes over. Net consequence is that amount of water supplied by evaporation decreases.
4) Weight of glacier depresses the surface of the land, so the surface elevation of ice sheet drops to lower (i.e. warmer) elevations.
5) The glacier starts to recede.
IV) What the future holds.
-
-
-
-
-
-
Effects of Past Glaciations on Plant and Animal Distributions
I. Causes of Glaciations
Ice ages are actually rare events in the Earth's 4.5 billion year history. In fact, the most recent ice ages occurred during the relatively recent Pleistocene epoch, beginning about two million years ago.
What initiates an ice age? We begin by first increasing the Earth's albedo, causing a loss of insolation. This increase in albedo began about 15 million years ago, when the Antarctic continent moved over the South Pole which led to the development of a permanent polar ice cap.
To supplement this change in albedo in the Southern Hemisphere, continental rearrangements about 3-
The Earth's albedo is about 33% as a whole, but the ice caps reflect about 80% of insolation, thus reducing the amount of energy retained by the Earth. The stage was set for development of an Ice Age.
But why hasn't the Earth remained uniformly cold in the last two million years? Why have we had alternating cold and warm spells? The most acceptable theory for the development of and ice age was put forward in the 1930s by the Yugoslav Milutin Milankovitch, who used a sequence of cyclic variations in the Earth itself.
First, variations in eccentricity: the Earth's orbit changes its elliptical pattern every 100,000 years, changing between a more circular orbit to one very elliptical. Circular orbits mean more uniform receipt of energy from season to season and from year to year.
Second, variations in obliquity: every 40,000 years, the tilt of the Earth's axis shifts between 21.8 and 24.4 degrees. A more severe tilt means a greater contrast in seasonal distribution of energy. A lower tilt means more uniform receipt of energy between the seasons. Also, the polar regions will receive more energy during periods with low tilt angles.
Third, variations in precession: the Earth's zenith changes every 21,000 years, changing from pointing to the North Star to another area, causing a precession of the equinoxes. For example, what was once the spring equinox will be the fall equinox 10,500-
All these effects will (1) change the total amount of insolation received, (2) change and redistribute the amount of insolation received latitudinally, and (3) change the insolation received temporally.
In 1976, for the first time, irrefutable evidence of these cycles was found in sediment cores taken from the deep ocean, confirming the Milankovitch Theory. These ocean sediments contain fossils that provide precise temperature variations.
The Milankovitch pattern has been found in sediments dating back eight million years, but one important change has been detected. Eight million years ago, the 100,000 year cycle was weak, but became stronger in the last two million years. This cycle has dominated the glacial/interglacial sequence, but why has its influence changed? The Earth's orbit can not change.
The answer lies in the ice masses themselves created during an ice age. The ice grows slowly but decays rapidly. The ice itself modifies global climate which enhances the effects of the 100,000 year cycle. The distribution of land masses and ocean bodies is a major contributing factor. Hence, the Milankovitch cycles just happened to accentuate an already declining situation with the movement of lithospheric plates.
Feedback effects also contributed to glaciations. For example, during warm interglacials, increased organic activity will lead to an increase in carbon dioxide and methane, confirmed in the ice core record from Greenland. These are greenhouse gases and contribute to warm the Earth during interglacials.
The anatomy of plants will change in response to glaciations. For example, during warm interglacials, plants will need fewer stomata (e.g., analyzing the stomatal density of subfossil plants) to uptake the carbon dioxide, and this has recently been proven.
Another theory concerning glaciations is the conveyor system that contributes to the North Atlantic Deep Water (NADW). Warm waters are brought to the North Atlantic in a conveyor system in deep ocean currents at about 800 meters. (Do not confuse this with surface circulation, such as the warm Gulf Stream.) This conveyor system effectively redistributes the energy surplus found around the equator to regions of energy deficit in the higher latitudes.
Fossil evidence shows this conveyor system became switched off during glacial periods, causing no warm water to reach the north Atlantic. This contributed to the intensification of polar cooling. However, scientists are unclear on what could shut down the conveyor system, perhaps changes in ocean salinity, and therefore the density of the deep ocean water.
Finally, a favorite theory proposed that may contribute to glacial periods is volcanic activity. An increase in volcanism will increase the amount of dust particles in the atmosphere, thus reducing the amount of insolation, and thereby reducing global temperatures.
Scientists have shown that volcanism has indeed increased during the most recent two million years! But why? This would suggest an increase in subductive activity at plate margins, and therefore an increase in convective activity within the Earth. Therefore, one must ask, do the origins of ice ages lie in variations of the temperature of the Earth's interior?
The increased dust particles would also contribute to increased precipitation as more condensation nuclei are found in the air. Both consequences would contribute to a general overall global cooling.
Throughout recent evolution, the environment continued to play an important role. To be sure, environmental changes act as the motor of evolution, allowing some life forms to adapt while forcing others to become extinct. And, on Earth, some of the most important environmental changes are caused by our climate.
Apart from seasonal changes taking place from month to month, and continental drifts occurring over millions of years, planet Earth apparently experiences global climatic changes that endure for thousands of years. For example, Figure 7.14 is a record of the average surface temperature during the past 500,000 years. These global climate data were obtained by a variety of methods, including analysis of core samples taken from the icy polar regions, of sandy sediments extracted from below the seafloor, and of land-
Figure 7.14FIGURE 7.14 -
ICE AGES:As shown by the plot, our planet has cycled through numerous episodes of cool, dry climate-
What causes these cycles of heating and cooling on our planet? Some geologists contend that glaciation increases during the periods of global volcanic activity when ejected dust reduces the amount of sunlight penetrating Earth's atmosphere. Others suggest that the periodic reversals in Earth's magnetic field cause the protective Van Allen Belts to disappear, thereby sporadically allowing unusually high doses of solar radiation to heat the ground and thus decrease glaciation. Still other researchers have noted that ice ages could be triggered on our planet by variations in the output of the Sun itself, by passage of Earth through an interstellar dust cloud, by deep circulation of Earth's oceans, or by any one of a long list of other proposals.
Recently, however, oceanographers have found convincing evidence to support yet another theory, dubbed the "Milankovitch effect" after the Yugoslavian geophysicist who proposed it earlier in this century. According to this theory, subtle though regular changes in Earth's orbit around the Sun initiate the ice ages. These changes are the combined result of three astronomical effects, each caused by the normal gravitational influence of other planets on the Earth: (1) changes in the shape (called "eccentricity") of Earth's elliptical orbit around the Sun, (2) changes in the tilt or wobble (called "precession") of Earth axis, and (3) changes in the orientation (called "obliquity") of Earth's tilt relative to its orbit, an effect caused by the ever-
Specifically, the shape of Earth's orbit changes approximately every 100,000 years, becoming more circular, then more elliptical. When the orbit is most elliptical, the Earth receives 20 to 30 percent more radiation when it is closest to the Sun than when it is most distant. Second, Earth wobbles on its axis every 26,000 years, thus changing the time in Earth's orbit when winter and summer occur. Finally, over a period of about 40,000 years, the tilt of the Earth (relative to its orbital plane) varies from 22.1 to 24.5 arc degrees, the smaller tilt resulting in smaller temperature differences between winter and summer.
The first phenomenon would produce warmer summers and colder winters. The second affects the heat mostly during the summer months, and conceivably the amount of ice melting. And the third probably results in cooler summers with less ice melting. The combination of these three effects-
This theory of an astronomically induced ice age is currently favored among the majority of scientists, mainly because samples of seafloor sediments show that during the past 500,000 years, tiny sea creatures called plankton have thrived at certain times, while barely surviving at others. Studies of the abundance of fossilized plankton known to prefer warm or cold water provide estimates of the prevailing water temperature during their lives. This inferred sea temperature correlates well with the expected heating and cooling of Earth by means of the combined astronomical effects just noted.
It seems, then, that slight peculiarities in Earth's orbital geometry are mainly responsible for triggering ice ages; whether they are the only trigger remains to be proved by further research.
Regardless of their cause, ice ages must have had profound effects on the evolution of life on Earth. The most recent major glaciation began about 75,000 years ago; the climate had returned to its present, "normal" state some 10,000 years ago. As depicted by Figure 7.15, at the peak of this ice age roughly 30,000 years ago, a kilometer-
Figure 7.15FIGURE 7.15 -
The last 10, 000 years have seen the glaciers retreat, the coastal plains flood, the vegetation climb toward northerly latitudes, and the ocean and atmosphere warm up. The change in climate from the peak of the most recent ice age to its present state occurred rapidly, by geological standards. These widespread changes in Earth's environment surely helped foster the many advances made by our human ancestors during this period of rich innovation. Humans were forced to adapt-
EARLY AMERICANS:The ice ages themselves may have accelerated the migration and colonization of new lands. For example, we know that humans did not evolve in the Americas; there is no fossil evidence for ape-
This is in fact the prevailing view; native North, Central, and South Americans are descendants of Asians who wandered here only a few hundred centuries ago. Once settled in the Americas, these migrants developed arts, languages, products, and numerous other cultural innovations. Whether the civilizations of the Americas experienced cultural evolution independent of those in Eurasia, or whether they had some as-
Internet Source Reference:
www.ldolphin.org/setterfield/earlyhist.html
A Summary of Creation and Catastrophe Geology
by Barry Setterfield
Introduction
The role that geological and astronomical catastrophes have played in the history of the solar system, and our planet in particular, has become more widely examined over the past 25 years [1]. In this new avenue of research, both astronomers and geologists have become aware of the important part played by impacting comets and/or asteroids [2]. One major segment of current geological inquiry concentrates on life-
A Clue from Light from Distant Galaxies
These two papers cite observational evidence that indicates light-
Another Clue from Meteorites
Some meteorites are taken to represent samples of material from the formation of the solar system and hence the Earth. For example, carbonaceous chondrites, may hold more than 20% water locked up in their mineral structures [6]. More specifically, carbonaceous chondrites of class CI are made up of hydrated silicates as well as the volatile components water, carbon dioxide, oxygen and nitrogen [7]. By way of an earthly example, the beautiful mineral serpentine is a hydrated silicate that contains 12.9% water in its composition [8]. Upon heating, this water is given up and the mineral turns to olivine, thereby reducing its volume [9]. Interestingly, olivine is an important component of the earth's mantle. In a similar way, other hydrated silicates, found in meteorites and on earth, may give up their water content when heated sufficiently, with a consequent reduction in volume. Indeed, the chondrules within the chondrite meteorites themselves are silicate spherules that have been melted and the volatile water component driven off. The remaining minerals in the chondrules contain a prominent amount of olivine [10].
The Role of Radioactive Decay
After creation week, the interior of the earth began to heat up from the rapid decay of short half-
The Asteroidal Planet Break-
Similar events were happening out in space. For instance, the original parent body (or bodies) of the current asteroids, which primarily inhabit the region between Mars and Jupiter, was undergoing a process paralleling that on earth. This process of short half-
It is acknowledged that radioactive heating from the short half-
Forming the Stable Shield Areas
Radioactive heating also continued on earth, with the first signs of molten rock intruded in the near-
Forming the Incipient Tectonic Plates
As serpentine changed to olivine, and other hydrated silicates lost their water content, there was a reduction in mineral volume. Consequently, the crust above the source areas for the water and magma would be weakened relative to the stable cratonic areas that had been solidly emplaced. This would be a major contributing factor to the predominantly vertical tectonic activity that generally dominated the Precambrian, instead of the horizontal forces of plate tectonics that predominated in the Mesozoic-
The Geology of Catastrophe 1.
The initiation of a series of geologically mobile belts bordering the shield areas of the super-
The Flood Layer in Geology
This event correlates well with the debris layer that is found on all continents, except India, a little below the boundary between the Proterozoic and the Cambrian. This debris layer is composed of pebbles, cobbles and boulders bound together in a cement-
Near Adelaide, in South Australia, this initial debris layer is over 300 metres thick [31], while the following deep-
The Second Catastrophe
The Palaeozoic Era that followed saw continuing deposition in intra-
Many insects would have survived the Flood on floating vegetation mats, which would have been much larger than, but similar to, the floating mats caused by lesser floods today. These are known to harbour a great deal of life. Even amphibians, while at home in the water, probably found the mats assisted survival. The insects and amphibians would be able to thrive in the moisture-
Meanwhile, the radioactive heating of the earth's interior continued. Eventually the stage was reached when significant portions of the upper mantle became molten. An episode of rampant volcanism would have followed. It produced the Siberian flood basalts, while associated earth movements resulted in massive tidal waves that swept huge quantities of vegetation into fault-
The Age of the Dinosaurs
During the Mesozoic Era that followed, active deposition of sediments took place around the rim of the super-
Much human and animal migration must have taken place during the two centuries of orbital time that this Era occupied before the worst phases of continental drift occurred. As the heating of the mantle continued, the mantle itself became increasingly mobile, Furthermore, a significant water content would have built up in the asthenosphere, a plastic layer at the base of the lithosphere that starts about 40 km below the surface [39]. The asthenosphere is, perhaps, the primary region involved in continental drift [39, 40], although some maintain that other parts of the mantle are involved as well [40]. This lubrication and mobility in the asthenosphere would have allowed the first movements of the tectonic plates, and the Mid-
The Continents Divide
On earth several asteroid impacts closed the Mesozoic Era, about 65 million atomic years ago at the Cretaceous/Tertiary boundary. The dinosaurs would have been decimated. Wild fires destroyed much vegetation. The layer of iridium from asteroid impacts and soot from the wild fires is virtually global. This was the time of Peleg in the fifth generation after the Flood (Luke 3:35-
The Beginnings of the Cenozoic Era
The large impact near the mid-
The high axis tilt, mountain building and volcanism would all contribute to annual extremes of climate. The mammals with their stable body temperatures were most able to cope with these conditions. Among the plants, the angiosperms became predominant with their seasonal flowering and fruit bearing. These plants include most deciduous trees, which are more able to withstand seasonal extremes. Continental drift would have resulted in isolated populations, which in turn would have brought about localised dominances. As the Era progressed, most giant forms would have died out due to new extremes of climate. From a study of oxygen isotope ratios in shells from the Atlantic, we know that ocean temperatures dropped progressively from the close of the Mesozoic throughout the Cenozoic Era that followed [45]. Once surface temperatures dropped below freezing, the initial stage of the ice-
The Ice-
Because of the destruction caused by these events, and the new rigorous weather conditions, numbers of people were probably forced to seek shelter in caves. They would have to get sustenance where they could find it, hunting animals, digging up roots and getting what food they could. Suitably shaped rocks would have had to suffice for weapons, even before wood and/or bone were used. After conditions had stabilised, and basic needs had been met, there would be time to re-
As those times were coming to a close, the 1st Dynasty in Egypt probably commenced. The discussion in "Creation and Catastrophe" [47] suggests that this event probably took place during the period 2783 BC to 2767 BC. About the same time, roughly 2765 BC, the main function governing light-
One More Global Catastrophe and Abraham
As the effects of the ice-
This brings us down to the less turbulent days of Abraham, who lived from 2304 to 2129 BC on the chronology adopted here. An archaeologist, Prof. D. N. Freedman of the University of Michigan made some important comments on this matter. As a result of the discovery of the Ebla tablets, written during the 23rd century BC, he commented: "It is now my belief that the story [about Abraham] in Genesis 14 not only corresponds in content to the Ebla Tablet, but that the Genesis account derives from the same period. Briefly put, the account in Genesis 14, and also in Chapters 18-
Summary
According to the astronomical data, light-
Enoch 65: 1-
1In those days Noah saw that the earth became inclined, and that destruction approached.
2Then he lifted up his feet, and went to the ends of the earth, to the dwelling of his great-
3And Noah cried with a bitter voice, Hear me; hear me; hear me: three times. And he said, Tell me what is transacting upon the earth; for the earth labours, and is violently shaken. Surely I shall perish with it.
4After this there was a great perturbation on earth, and a voice was heard from heaven. I fell down on my face, when my great-
9Afterwards my great-
Chapter 65
1After this he showed me the angels of punishment, who were prepared to come, and to open all the mighty waters under the earth:
2That they may be for judgment, and for the destruction of all those who remain and dwell upon the earth.
3And the Lord of spirits commanded the angels who went forth, not to take up the men and preserve them.
4For those angels presiding over all the mighty waters. Then I went out from the presence of Enoch.
Enoch 66: 13-
13In those days shall the waters of that valley be changed; for when the angels shall be judged, then shall the heat of those springs of water experience an alteration.
14And when the angels shall ascend, the water of the springs shall again undergo a change, and be frozen. Then I heard holy Michael answering and saying, This judgment, with which the angels shall be judged, shall bear testimony against the kings, the princes, and those who possess the earth.
Ethiopian Book Of Enoch
Note from Author, Malik Jabbar: These excerpts from the Book Of Enoch are focused on ancient scripture that reports shifts in the Orbit and Axis inclination of our planet. I will cover this subject and explain the Cycles in Book Four.
Source:
A Modern English Translation
of the Ethiopian Book of Enoch
with introduction and notes by
Andy McCracken
Special thanks to Bredren Jason Naphtali
who found this translation (by M. Knibb) of the Ethiopian text in the
S.O.A.S. Library at the University of London.
11) THE BOOK OF NOAH
65.1 And in those days, Noah saw the Earth had tilted and that its destruction was near.
65.2 And he set off from there and went to the ends of the Earth and cried out to his great-
65.3 And he said to him: "Tell me, what is it that is being done on the Earth, that the Earth is so afflicted and shaken, lest I be destroyed with it!"
65.4 And immediately there was a great disturbance on the Earth and a voice was heard from Heaven and I fell upon my face.
65.5 And my great-
65.6 And a command has gone out from the Lord against those who dwell upon the dry ground that this must be their end. For they have learnt all the secrets of the Angels, and all the wrongdoings of the satans, and all their secret power, and all the power of those who practice magic arts, and the power of enchantments, and the power of those who cast molten images for all the Earth.
65.7 And further, how silver is produced from the dust of the earth and how soft metal occurs on the earth.
65.8 For lead and tin are not produced from the earth, like the former; there is a spring which produces them, and an Angel who stands in it, and that Angel distributes them."
65.9 And after this, my great-